This is about Sam, who has a work from home job, who recently proposed to his girlfriend and made plans for a wedding which is due in six months.
****
Sam strolled into the quiet kitchen, the aroma of Anjali’s morning chai enveloping him in comfort. He was the first to rise in their little suburban bungalow, his footsteps the only sound echoing through the cool tiles. The soft light from the window cast a gentle glow on the neatly arranged countertops, hinting at the promise of a new day. Anjali, his girlfriend of five years and his soon to be wife, was still asleep, her breathing deep and steady.
His thoughts wandered to Ananya, the middle sister among Anjali’s siblings. She had always been the bubbly one, a whirlwind of energy and laughter, and her visits were usually filled with light-hearted banter and good-natured teasing. Yet, there was something about her that had always intrigued him. Perhaps it was the way her eyes sparkled when she talked about her dreams, or the way she moved with a grace that seemed to defy her clumsiness. Despite his affection for her, he had never seen her as more than a sibling-in-law.
Priya, the youngest of Anjali’s two sisters, was the complete opposite. Reserved and contemplative, she often remained in the background, her gentle smile a silent commentary on the world around her. Sam had had more in-depth conversations with Priya than he had with Ananya, finding her insights to be surprisingly mature beyond her years. Yet, there was a wall between them that neither had ever cared to breach.
Sam began his day in the peaceful kitchen, reflecting on his sisters-in-law Ananya and Priya. Ananya was lively and clumsy, often the center of attention with her bright spirit, while Priya was quieter and introspective, sharing meaningful conversations with a surprising maturity. Despite their differences, Sam saw them both as family members and enjoyed their company during visits.
On one of Ananya’s frequent visits, she had come to Sam looking rather flustered. “Sam,” she panted, her cheeks flushed, “I had a little accident. I fell off my scooter, and now my body is aching all over.”
Sam’s brows furrowed in concern. “Are you okay?” He reached out to help her sit at the kitchen table, his hand lingering a moment too long on her waist.
“I think I just need to rest,” Ananya replied, wincing as she gingerly sat down. Her eyes searched his, looking for reassurance. “Maybe a massage would help?”
Surprise flickered in Sam’s eyes before he nodded. “I can do that for you. Just tell me where it hurts the most.”
He went to the living room to grab some oil from the drawer where Anjali kept her massage supplies. The house was still, the only sound the occasional creak of the floorboards. When he returned, Ananya had taken off her sweater, revealing a simple white tank top that clung to her dainty frame. The room felt suddenly warmer, the air thick with a tension neither of them acknowledged.
He began to massage her shoulders, his strong hands moving in smooth, practiced circles. Ananya sighed, the tension in her body visibly easing. They talked about her job at the local bookstore, the latest romance novel she was reading, and the antics of the family’s old dog, Bella. The conversation flowed easily, filling the room with a gentle hum of familiarity.
As Sam’s hands worked their magic, Ananya leaned into his touch, her breathing becoming more ragged. He noticed the way her eyes fluttered shut and her cheeks grew redder. The innocent act of kindness had transformed into something more, something neither of them had anticipated.
Priya walked into the kitchen, her footsteps silent on the tiles. She stopped short at the sight of her sister and brother-in-law. Sam’s hands froze for a moment before continuing, his eyes meeting Priya’s in a silent exchange. He felt a pang of guilt, but she merely nodded and busied herself with making toast, the slice of bread popping up from the toaster with a soft click.
The atmosphere grew heavier as Ananya turned to face him, her eyes searching his. He knew he should stop, but something held him there. Was it the way Ananya’s body felt under his touch, the way she leaned into him like a flower to the sun? Or was it the sudden realization that the naive young girl he had always thought her to be was now a woman with desires of her own?
Without a word, Priya slipped out of the kitchen, leaving Sam and Ananya in an awkward silence. The air between them crackled with unspoken emotions, and for a moment, it was as if the entire world had stopped spinning. Ananya looked down, her lashes brushing against her cheeks. “I’m okay now,” she murmured, her voice barely above a whisper.
Sam nodded, his throat dry. He knew that this moment would change everything, that the lines they had crossed could not be uncrossed. But as Ananya slipped away to recover in the guest room, he couldn’t help but wonder what would happen next. Would they ignore the spark that had been kindled, or would it grow into something that could threaten the very fabric of their family? The only certainty was that nothing would ever be the same again.
The day dragged on, filled with forced smiles and stolen glances. Anjali remained blissfully unaware of the undercurrents rippling through the house, chatting with Ananya about her latest recipes and Priya’s latest art project. Sam tried to focus on his work, but his mind kept drifting back to Ananya’s soft sighs and the feel of her skin under his fingertips.
That evening, as they all sat down to dinner, the tension was palpable. The clinking of cutlery against plates sounded like a cacophony in the heavy silence. Priya, ever the observant one, cast a knowing look in Sam’s direction, but said nothing. Ananya, on the other hand, was unusually quiet, pushing her food around the plate with a distracted air.
After dinner, Ananya excused herself early, and returned to her home where her boyfriend, Nish was waiting.
Sam struggled with his feelings following Ananya’s retreat to her home. In the quiet of the night, as Anjali’s gentle snores filled their bedroom, Sam lay awake, staring at the ceiling. He couldn’t shake the feeling that he was standing on the edge of a cliff, the wind whispering seductive secrets in his ear. Ananya’s eyes, filled with a mix of pain and longing, haunted him.
The next morning, Ananya came back to see Anjali, her usual cheerfulness a mask over the shadows in her eyes. Sam knew he had to talk to her, to set things right, but every time he opened his mouth, the words got tangled in the guilt that gripped his throat.
Finally, unable to bear the silence any longer, he approached her as she was about to leave. “Ananya,” he began, his voice shaky, “about yesterday…”
Her smile was forced, but she cut him off with a wave of her hand. “It’s okay, Sam. Really. I know you were just trying to help.”
Sam nodded, the unspoken understanding hanging heavily between them. They both knew it was more than that, but for now, the truth remained unspoken. As she left the house, climbing onto her scooter with more confidence than the previous day, he watched her go with a mix of relief and regret.
The days that followed were a blur of half-hearted conversations and awkward silences. The dynamics in the house had shifted, the invisible barriers between them now stark and unyielding. Yet, Sam couldn’t shake the feeling that this was only the beginning of a storm that had been brewing for far too long.
One afternoon, as Ananya was about to leave for work, she stopped by her sister’s house where Sam was sipping his tea. She looked at him with a mix of vulnerability and determination. “I need to talk to you,” she said, her voice barely above a whisper.
Sam’s heart skipped a beat. He nodded, setting down his cup with a clatter that seemed to shatter the tension. They walked to the small patio at the back of the house, the warm sun doing little to alleviate the chill in the air. Ananya took a deep breath, her eyes searching his. “What happened between us… it can’t happen again,” she said, her voice firm despite the tremble in her hands.
Sam nodded, his own hands clenching into fists by his sides. “I know,” he agreed, his voice thick with unspoken apologies. “I never meant to…”
“It’s not just about me,” Ananya interrupted, her eyes filling with unshed tears. “It’s about Anjali, about Priya, about our entire family. We can’t let this ruin what we have.”
Her words hit him like a ton of bricks. He knew she was right, but the thought of pushing away the connection they had discovered was like cutting off a part of himself. He took a step closer, reaching out to her, but she took a step back, shaking her head.
“No,” she said, her voice firm. “We can’t do this. It’s wrong, and we both know it.”
The next time Ananya visited, he was distant, his interactions with her polite but guarded. He watched as she tried to bridge the gap, her smiles not quite reaching her eyes, and felt a pang of loss. But he knew that this was for the best, that he had to protect his marriage and his family from the tempest that threatened to consume them.
As Ananya prepared to leave, she lingered by the door, her eyes meeting his one last time. “Thank you,” she murmured, her voice thick with emotion.
Sam nodded, his throat tight. “Take care,” he said, his voice gruff.
The door clicked shut behind her, and the house felt emptier than it ever had before. He knew that he had made the right choice, but the ache inside him was undeniable. The spark between them had been extinguished, but the scars remained, a constant reminder of what could have been.
In the following weeks, Ananya’s visits grew fewer and farther between. Sam could feel the distance growing between them, a chasm that seemed to widen with each passing day. He missed her laughter, her boundless energy, and the way she had made his heart race. Yet, every time they did cross paths, Ananya was careful to maintain her composure, her smile never quite reaching her eyes. It was a dance of pretending that they had never shared that moment of intimacy.
One day, Ananya called, her voice small and unsure. “Sam,” she began, “I need to see you.”
He felt his stomach flip, a mix of dread and anticipation coiling in his gut. He knew that this conversation was long overdue, the unspoken tension between them a constant reminder of the line they had crossed.
They met at a small café on the outskirts of town, a place they had never been to together before. Ananya sat across from him, her eyes red-rimmed, and he could see the pain etched into her features. “I can’t do this anymore,” she whispered, her voice cracking. “This… pretending.”
Sam took a deep breath, his hands clenching around his coffee cup. “I know,” he said, his voice barely above a murmur. “I’ve been trying to keep my distance.”
“But why?” she asked, her voice filled with a desperation that made him want to reach across the table and hold her. “Why are we doing this to ourselves?”
He searched her eyes, looking for the answer that had eluded him for so long. “Because it’s wrong,” he said, his voice heavy with the weight of his conviction. “Because we could hurt so many people.”
Sam felt the world spin around him. He had never allowed himself to entertain the thought, had never dared to believe that their connection could be more than a fleeting moment of weakness. But looking into her eyes, he knew that she was right. It was something more, something that could either build them up or tear them apart.
The drive home was a blur of thoughts and emotions. He knew he had made a promise to Ananya, but the pull towards her was stronger than ever. The realization hit him like a wave: he wanted his wife’s sister, and no amount of willpower or good intentions could change that. The question now was, how could they navigate this minefield of emotions without losing themselves, or each other, in the process?
The next day, Ananya returned to the house, her eyes avoiding his as she greeted him with a forced smile. Anjali was out with friends, leaving Sam and Ananya alone in the quiet of the afternoon. “Sam,” she began, her voice trembling slightly, “my body is still in a lot of pain from the fall. I was wondering if you could… if it’s okay… if you could give me another massage.”
His heart raced as he nodded, the memory of their last encounter playing in his mind like a haunting melody. He led her to the same chair in the living room, his hands shaking as he poured the warm oil onto her shoulders. As he began to massage her, the tension in the room was palpable, a silent symphony of unspoken words and unmet gazes.
Ananya leaned into his touch, her eyes closed in feigned relaxation. But he could feel the tension coiled in her muscles, the way she held her breath when his fingers brushed against her skin. It was as if she was bracing herself for something more, something that neither of them could ignore.
As Sam worked his way down her back, Ananya’s breath grew shallower, and she bit her bottom lip to stifle a gasp. The line between pain relief and something else had been crossed, and they both knew it. He paused, his hand hovering over her lower back, and she opened her eyes to look at him.
Their gazes locked, and in that moment, the air thick with unspoken confessions, Sam knew that he couldn’t go on like this. He had to tell Anjali, had to come clean about what had happened between them. It was a conversation that would shake their marriage to its core, but he knew it was the only way to move forward with any semblance of honesty.
“Ananya,” he said, his voice hoarse, “we need to stop this. We need to tell Anjali.”
But Ananya’s eyes pleaded with him, and she whispered, “Just… keep going, Sam. For today, just pretend it’s not wrong. I need this… I need you.”
Against his better judgment, Sam’s hands continued to move, the warm oil a slick barrier between his skin and hers. The tension in Ananya’s body slowly melted away, and she leaned into his touch with a sigh that was half pain, half pleasure. He could feel her resolve crumbling, the boundaries between them dissolving like sugar in tea.
As the room grew darker with the setting sun, Ananya turned to face him, her expression a mix of longing and desperation. “Sam,” she murmured, her voice a siren’s call, “I can’t keep pretending. I know it’s wrong, but today… today, I want you.”
*****
This is a long series guys, so please be patient. The juicy stuff will come soon.
Please send your comments and feedback to [email protected].
Thank you all for reading.